I need to remove commercial and not convert

I followed:

I set comskip (donator ver) and filter on Mpeg4

I use Playon to record, it did in mpeg4 and mp4. It chose the new profile, however it still converted the video

I am running the latest MceBuddy 2.4.8 beta.

[MP$ cut commercial]
Profile=MP4 High Quality
DestinationPath=C:\Video
WorkingPath=
FallbackDestination=False
CheckReprocessingHistory=False
AddToiTunesLibrary=False
AddToWMPLibrary=False
AutoIncrementFilename=False
SkipReprocessing=False
MaxWidth=1920
FPS=
VolumeMultiplier=0
QualityMultiplier=1
RenameBySeries=True
AltRenameBySeries=True
CustomRenameBySeries=
RenameOnly=False
DownloadSeriesDetails=True
DownloadBanner=True
OverwriteTitleIMDB=False
FileSelection=
MetaSelection=
MetaChannelSelection=
MonitorTaskNames=
DRC=True
AudioLanguage=
AudioOffset=0
InsertQueueTop=False
ExtractXML=False
WriteMetadata=True
AutoDeInterlace=True
PreferHardwareEncoding=True
StereoAudio=True
EncoderSelectBestAudioTrack=True
DisableCropping=False
StartTrim=0
EndTrim=0
ExtractCC=
CCOffset=2.5
EmbedSubtitlesChapters=False
ExtractAdsFromChapters=False
PrioritizeOriginalBroadcastDateMatch=False
TaskCommercialSkipCut=False
SkipCopyBackup=False
SkipRemux=False
IgnoreCopyProtection=False
TiVOMAKKey=
Enabled=True
ForceShowType=Default
MetaShowTypeSelection=Default
MetaCodecSelection=Mpeg4
MetaDRMTypeSelection=All
CommercialRemoval=Comskip
ComskipINI=
DomainName=
UserName=
MetaCorrectionsCount=0

Vern
Vern,

Attach your MCEBuddy.log file and include the filename for the video

Here are both the file log and mcebuddy log.
Battlestar Galactica - s04e23 - Daybreak, Part 3.mp4-MP$ cut commercial-2017-11-15T16-46-02.8112617-05-00.log (1.8 KB)
mcebuddy.log (180.2 KB)Battlestar Galactica - s04e23 - Daybreak, Part 3.edl.txt (40 Bytes)

I disabled HW acceleration and cleared the MCE buddy log. reran:

MCEBuddy Battlestar
Battlestar Galactica - s04e23 - Daybreak, Part 3.mp4-MP$ cut commercial-2017-11-15T19-35-00.8032368-05-00 - Copy.log (1015.0 KB)
the above log is before it kicked off pass 2

Set your logs to debug. These are practically empty.